13 of The SecondHand Shops and Best Thrift Stores in NJ

One way to reduce your environmental impact is to shop secondhand. If you've read our article on the benefits of thrift shopping, you're probably ready to explore what the great state of NJ has to offer. New Jersey is home to a variety of incredible thrift stores and consignment shops. Whether you're on the hunt for vintage clothing, household items, or unique furniture, NJ has it all. Organized by North, Central, and Southern NJ, this list of the best thrift stores in NJ will help you find your next second-hand shopping destination.

We've compiled this list based on places we've visited and Google reviews. Be sure to add to the comments section to find the best thrift stores in your area!

All Over the State

Over the years, second hand stores have expanded into chains. Regardless of where you live, you'll likely be able to find a location near you.

1. Plato’s Closet

Plato’s Closet buys and sells gently used clothes, shoes and accessories, so you can recycle the items you no longer wear and get paid on the spot. Each location is individually owned and operated by local business owners, so you can feel good about shopping small.

What to Expect: This is a resale shop focusing on trendy clothing for teens and young adults. It's a great store if you’re looking for like-new items at a cheap price.
Pros: Budget-friendly, affordable prices with a focus on popular brands.
Cons: Limited vintage finds and mostly contemporary styles. Only clothing.
Best Locations: Look for them in Jersey City, Princeton, and Hudson County.

2. Goodwill

Goodwill is an American Non-Profit organization that provides job training, employment placement services and other community-based programs for people who face barriers in their employment. Along with accepting donations, they provide charity work as well.

What to Expect: A local favorite offering everything from women’s clothing to household goods and small appliances.
Pros: A great selection of home items and second-hand clothing.
Cons: These are the most popular shops so finding unique items might be difficult.
Ideal Locations: Visit their stores in Blackwood, Pompton Plains, and Bound Brook.

3. Salvation Army Thrift Stores

The Salvation Army is a Protestant Christian church and an international charitable organization headquartered in London, England. It is the largest non-government provider of social services in the United States and one of the largest in the world. They offer services for people in need and collect

What to Expect: A good place to shop while supporting adult rehabilitation centers. They offer furniture donations, household items, and clothing.
Best Locations: Union City and Turnersville are great spots.

Northern New Jersey

We're focusing on this section of NJ to find the best thrift shops in northern NJ. See our recommendations below:

4. Udelco (Hawthorne)

Google Review: 4.3/5.0

What to Expect: This vintage shop is a treasure trove of vintage finds, featuring items from the 1960s.
Pros: Amazing prices and a wide variety of vintage clothing.
Cons: Requires patience to sort through its large selection. Clothing only.
Ideal For: Those who love vintage stores and don't mind a good hunt.

5. Renaissance Consignment Boutique (Maplewood)

Google Review: 4.9/5.0

What to Expect: Perfect for high-end fashion and consignment furniture, including glass boxes and home decor.
Pros: A great shop for women’s clothing and unique pieces.
Cons: Limited selection for men.

6. Market Street Mission Thrift Shop (Morristown)

Google Review: 4.4/5.0

What to Expect: A small shop with quality items supporting a good cause.
Pros: Friendly staff, great prices, and furniture donations help the broader community.
Cons: Smaller inventory.

7. Thriftnicks (East Rutherford)

Google Review: 4.3/5.0

What to Expect: A great store for collectibles, vinyl records, and household items.
Pros: Amazing prices and a fun mix of second-hand treasures.
Cons: Limited social media presence.

8. Woodstock Vibes (Various Locations)

Google Review: 4.3/5.0

What to Expect: A family-run store offering lightly used clothing at reasonable prices.
Pros: Friendly volunteers and a personal touch.
Cons: Limited vintage clothing.

Central New Jersey

9. Inspiration (Elizabeth)

Google Review: 4.4/5.0

What to Expect: A great place for second-hand clothing, home goods, and furniture.
Pros: Large selection with reasonable prices.
Cons: Requires effort to sift through items.

10. Yellow Tag (Green Brook)

Google Review: 3.2/5.0

What to Expect: A consignment shop offering everything from clothing to gowns to small pieces of furniture.
Pros: Perfect for a treasure hunt. They often have sales around holidays so be sure to check them out on a holiday weekend!
Cons: Cramped layout and limited accessibility for some shoppers.

11. Center Square Thrift Shop (Belmar)

Google Review: 4.7/5.0

What to Expect: Located on Main Street, this shop supports a good cause and offers unique items.
Pros: Wide selection of second-hand clothing and accessories.
Cons: Limited online store presence.

Southern New Jersey

12. 2nd Ave Thrift Superstore (Pennsauken)

Google Review: 4.2/5.0

What to Expect: This is one of the most popular stores for thrift shopping in NJ, with an enormous selection of items.
Pros: Great deals on clothing, toys, and seasonal decor.
Cons: Inventory can be overwhelming.

13. Spouses of JBMDL Org Thrift Store (McGuire AFB)

Google Review: 4.8/5.0

What to Expect: A good place for furniture donations, baby gear, and clothing.
Pros: Great deals and unique finds for military families.
Cons: Limited accessibility for non-military patrons.

Why Thrifting in NJ is Worth It

From vintage clothing to household items, NJ thrift stores offer a little bit of everything for everyone. Whether you're looking to find a unique piece for your dining room or browse small shops for hidden gems, these stores have hidden treasures for everyone. So, head out to your current location and start exploring the amazing prices and great deals these shops have to offer!

Don't' forget to comment below what your favorite store is and if I missed any in the list!

Happy thrifting!